Grass Range, Montana · Ranching since 1975Local roots · Global fieldwork · National voice

Policy & testimony

Price Discrepancies, Transparency and Unfair Practices in Cattle Markets

Summary

Price Discrepancies, Transparency and Unfair Practices in Cattle Markets is a policy & testimony record by Gilles Stockton concerning federal policy. This permanent archive page preserves its publication context, date (April 27), subjects and access to the original U.S. House testimony source.

Central question

What does this record contribute to the public debate over federal policy?

Subjects and context

Cattle & beefMarkets & competitionPublic policy

This record is catalogued independently from its original host. The external source remains active so readers can inspect the original document or publication while the permanent Gilles Stockton archive is assembled.

Complete verified text

Price Discrepancies, Transparency and Unfair Practices in Cattle Markets

By Gilles Stockton

Mr. Chairman and Members of the Committee, thank you for the opportunity to address you today on the urgent issue of price discrepancies, transparency, and unfair practices in our cattle markets.

My name is Gilles Stockton. I raise sheep and cattle near Grass Range, Montana. Today, I am representing the Northern Plains Resource Council, the Western Organization of Resource Councils, and the Montana Cattlemen’s Association, organizations that work to preserve family agriculture and the rural communities upon which we depend. I took over the family ranch from my parents in 1975, the same year that I graduated from Montana State University with a master’s degree in Animal Science.

When my wife and I started ranching in 1975 we had no assets except for our degrees. We were fortunate to have support from my parents and a loan from the Farmers Home Administration. It was not easy, but we were able to make it work. In 2022, a young couple starting with the situation that we had would find it impossible to make a living in production agriculture. The economic reality simply does not allow it. We are losing an entire generation of farmers and ranchers, the people upon which many of our Montana communities are built.

In 1975, 25 percent of the beef packing industry was controlled by four firms. Today, approximately 85 percent of the beef packing industry is controlled by four firms. This corporate concentration is underlying and shaping the economic reality that prevents farmers and ranchers from thriving. Monopoly power extracts wealth from rural communities and takes a larger share of the retail dollar away from producers like me. From 2012–2017, in Fergus County, Montana, where I am from and the number one cattle-producing county in the state, we have seen devastating losses. In these five years, our county reported a 14 percent decline in market value of products sold per farm, and a 54 percent decline of net cash farm income per farm. In my community of Grass Range, I’ve seen this play out as a main street which now has only one functional business.

In 1975, the farm-to-retail price spread for beef was 71.3 percent. That means for each $1 spent on beef at the grocery store, 71.3 cents made it back into the pockets of ranchers and cattle feeders. We spent that money in our communities, at truck dealers and farm suppliers, restaurants and grocery stores. In 2021, that spread was just 36.5 percent. This means that ranchers and feeders have lost half of the value of the beef that we raise to the packing and retail cartels that have come to dominate the beef industry over the course of my lifetime as a rancher. Our profit share declined, and consumers pay higher prices for beef.

I carry with me my own experience over five decades. For example, in 1979, I purchased a one-ton four-wheel-drive truck with the proceeds of selling 18 steer calves. The equivalent truck today would cost me 59 steer calves. No wonder our local businesses have not survived.

That share of the beef dollar we’ve lost does not come back to me and my fellow ranchers, or my community. Marginal rises in prices for cattle, if appearing at all, are seasonal and volatile at best, and cannot be relied upon for feeders and ranchers who struggle to make ends meet and cannot be guaranteed a fair shake at date of sale.

I do not want you to get the impression that I am looking for sympathy, far from it. I have had a wonderful life, working in an occupation that I love. I have had experiences as a routine part of my day that many people can just dream of. I have been blessed to have two wonderful women willing to put up with me. My first wife passed away in 2003. Between us, we have three sons, one of whom has volunteered to look after my sheep, which are currently having their lambs. Without his help, I could not be here today.

My concern is for my community, the future of agriculture, and the future of food security for this nation. My community of Grass Range has over the course of my life as a rancher dried up and blown away like a tumbleweed.

There is no part of the U.S. agricultural system that is not harmed by monopoly corporate power, but the beef sector and its experience during the pandemic may be the example of this that is most visible today. The disruptions during the pandemic revealed how vulnerable the beef and pork supply chain is. The lack of basic protections for workers that contributed to rampant illness in the packing plants slowed the processing of cattle, with the result of empty shelves in the meat counter. Ranchers like myself and my neighbors were suddenly unable to sell our cattle, and were left desperately scrambling to find a buyer. Many could only find a ‘take it or leave it’ price that was far below our cost. Prices to consumers skyrocketed, when they could find beef on the shelf at all. And the big four packers profited from buying cattle for less and selling beef for more.

The packers have said that this is all about supply and demand, but it is also about having our entire meat production system funneled through a very narrow bottleneck, where a few big packers can exploit both producers and consumers.

The big four packers exercise their concentrated market power to maximize their profits through the use of captive supplies: cattle that packers either own outright or have a commitment for delivery through formula contracts, which are also called Alternative Marketing Arrangements or AMAs. Most of the remaining purchases are made on the cash market, referred to as the negotiated spot market.

These captive supplies, which at times amount to three-quarters of the market, allow for packer price manipulation. When cattle are sold in an open, public market with multiple buyers on a level playing field, the competitive bidding results in price discovery that reaches a sale price that reflects the true value. Even smaller buyers will bid on many more cattle than they ultimately purchase, and are therefore important competitors to even the largest packers. Use of captive supplies also allows packers to offer sweetheart deals to select ranchers and feeders. Prices to these operators have declined over time as well, but they make incrementally more than independent ranchers and feeders, who often face uncertainty over whether they will be able to sell their cattle at all.

As increasing amounts of cattle are sold outside of an open market, prices decline. For every one percent increase in the level of captive supply, there is a 5.9 percent decrease in the price of cattle according to a study by Nathan Miller and others of Georgetown University. With captive supply levels now approaching 80 percent of all fed cattle, you can readily see how much ranchers and feeders are losing in this rigged market system. Another study, in this case from Iowa State University, shows that the big four packers are leveraging their power across multiple plants, further eroding true price discovery in the cattle market.

The effect of captive supplies on U.S. cattle markets was demonstrated in 2003, when mad cow disease was detected in Canada, and imports of Canadian live cattle to the U.S. were banned. Canadian imports made up less than five percent of the U.S. slaughter at the time, and were all captive supplies. Within months of the Canadian border closure, U.S. fed cattle prices jumped an unprecedented $26 per hundredweight, or about $325 per head.

Last summer in a Senate Agriculture Committee hearing, Senator Grassley of Iowa revealed that packers were making over $1,000 per head profits for owning the cattle for just a few days. Ranchers and feeders were losing money on each head raised, and consumers were paying more.

What to do? Actually, it is not that complicated, and the solutions can be executed through this Committee.

The first solution is mandatory Country of Origin Labeling. Meatpackers oppose COOL because they don’t think consumers should have the right to know where their beef comes from, and they want to be able to use international livestock trade to help keep the prices they pay producers low. With other food and manufactured items, consumers are able to exercise choice on where purchases are sourced, except for beef and pork. Consumers overwhelmingly support mandatory Country of Origin Labeling, or COOL, and demonstrated that they are willing to pay more for U.S. beef and pork when COOL was fully in effect between 2013 and 2016. Consumer demand for U.S. beef and cattle prices increased. Unfortunately, after an adverse WTO ruling, Congress repealed COOL in 2015, before the dispute process had been completed, but it is still possible to negotiate a settlement that will allow mandatory COOL to be reinstated by passing the American Beef Labeling Act. H.R. 7291 will once again give consumers the ability to know where their beef comes from, which is a prerequisite in order to reignite competition at the retail level, and for cattle producers to have a fair and transparent market.

The second policy that’s needed is to require that the beef packers purchase their cattle in a competitive and transparent marketplace that they neither own nor control. USDA can do this through rules under the Packers and Stockyards Act, or Congress can do so by strengthening amendments to the Act to require this free-enterprise approach to antitrust enforcement. In fact, your colleagues from a century ago used this method to restore competition to the cattle industry.

Forward contracts and alternative marketing agreements for slaughter livestock should be offered or bid in an open, public market and contain a fixed base price—one that can be equated with a specific dollar amount on the day the contract is entered. Livestock owned and fed by packers more than 14 days before slaughter should also be sold through an open, public market.

The Cattle Price Discovery and Transparency Act, currently being considered in the Senate, is a step forward to increase the percentage of cattle purchased on the cash market, but falls short in restoring competition to cattle markets.

Creating a fair, open, and competitive marketplace for cattle producers is important because our food and economic security depend on it. We must act now for ourselves and future generations. As states across the West, including Montana, are dealing with a megadrought, wildfires, and economic devastation, we don’t have time for baby steps and false solutions. We need bold and transformative change. Mr. Chairman, I urge you and the Committee to pass the American Beef Labeling Act and reintroduce and pass the Captive Supply Reform Act.

Thank you for the opportunity to speak to these issues.

Original source

Read or download the verified source held by U.S. Government Publishing Office — House Agriculture Committee hearing record.

View the original record