Policy & testimony
Livestock-Market Concentration Testimony
Summary
Livestock-Market Concentration Testimony is a policy & testimony record by Gilles Stockton concerning montana policy. This permanent archive page preserves its publication context, date (February 8), subjects and access to the original Montana Senate record source.
Central question
What does this record contribute to the public debate over montana policy?
Subjects and context
This record is catalogued independently from its original host. The external source remains active so readers can inspect the original document or publication while the permanent Gilles Stockton archive is assembled.
Complete verified text
Livestock-Market Concentration Testimony
Archive note: Complete two-page written testimony transcribed from the official scanned exhibit. Capitalization, numbered paragraphs and original order are preserved in substance; line breaks and evident OCR errors were normalized for readability.
My name is Gilles Stockton. I raise cattle and sheep near Grass Range and I am testifying on behalf of Northern Plains Resource Council.
Perhaps you are questioning why the Legislature is being asked to consider a resolution so similar to the one that was passed overwhelmingly just two years ago.
This resolution, for an interim study, is an opportunity for the Legislature to assess the impact of beef and lamb concentration on Montana’s producers and Montana’s economy. This is an opportunity to determine what can be done to counteract this threat.
Since the Legislature passed a similar resolution in 1989, some disturbing information has been published.
According to the NCA Task Force Report on Integration and Concentration, ‘The cow-calf sector likely will evolve to large, well capitalized, commercial producers and small “part time” producers with most of their income from off-farm sources or other farming enterprises.’ The report goes on to say that ‘cow-calf concentration is expected to take place at a relatively rapid pace.’
Dr. Wallace Rehberg, an agricultural economist from Washington State University, is quoted to say, ‘We will see the demise of the mid-size herd. The remaining large cattlemen will grow cattle on contract to the feedlot rather than selling through the market.’
92.8% of Montana’s 17,900 livestock producers are midsized or smaller. Can our rural communities survive the elimination of this many of its citizens?
The 1990 marketing season for lamb has disturbing implications. Excessive market power by one lamb packer and a handful of Eastern wholesalers has devastated the income of Montana sheepmen. In 1987 I sold feeder lambs for $1.01. In 1990 I received 46 cents.
In this week’s Billings Gazette I read that Dr. Myles Watts, agricultural economist at MSU, predicts that ‘cattle prices would remain strong for the next year or two, as long as the national herd does not increase.’ He goes on to observe that the herd has increased 1% in this past year.
Montana’s producers are extremely concerned. But it is not just producers who should worry. Agriculture accounts for around 40% of business activity in Montana. Sheep and cattle produce over half of that income. This state’s economy cannot afford further reductions. Remember it is profits that are spent in Main Street businesses—not losses.
The failure of the farm economy during the 1980s is responsible for the lack of population growth. We’ve lost a Congressional seat. We’ve seen our children move out of state. Rural communities cannot recruit physicians. But that doesn’t matter because we can’t afford health insurance anyway. We are in a world of hurt.
Yes, the failures in policies came from Washington. But you, Montana’s legislators, must deal with the consequences. You are struggling to provide essential services on an inadequate tax base. It looks to me to be an impossible and thankless task. Unless the concentration of power in the livestock industry is checked, the Legislature ten years from today will have an even more impossible situation.
This interim study will give you the opportunity to assess the problem and consider what Montana can do to counteract it. We cannot sit on our hands and hope that someone else will solve this problem. We must actively look for our own solutions.
Original source
Read or download the verified source held by Montana Senate Agriculture, Livestock and Irrigation Committee — Exhibit 1 to SJR 14.
View the original record